Dolphins Debate: Should Kelly Promote Backup QB? | Opinion

The Miami Dolphins are at a crossroads, with discussions intensifying around the quarterback position. In recent analysis, the potential promotion of a backup quarterback has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike. This comes in the wake of the Dolphins considering Nathaniel Hackett for their quarterback coach role.

Dolphins’ Quarterback Situation: A Look Ahead

Hackett’s past experiences, including working with star quarterback Aaron Rodgers, place him in an intriguing position. He also shares a history with Malik Willis, who is a free-agent quarterback linked to Miami. New head coach Jeff Hafley and general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan are both familiar with Willis, which adds a layer of complexity to the Dolphins’ plans.

The Legacy of Quarterbacks in Miami

Historically, the Dolphins have seen mixed results with quarterbacks. In 2000, Jay Fiedler was promoted from backup to starter. Fiedler led the team to a respectable winning percentage of 67% during his early seasons. However, he ultimately fell short as a long-term solution.

Despite Fiedler’s success, many believe the franchise wasted a strong defensive era, led by legends like Jason Taylor and Zach Thomas. This raises questions about whether similar mistakes will recur under Hafley’s leadership.

Malik Willis: A Potential Prospect

• Background: Willis was a third-round pick by the Tennessee Titans.
• Performance: In two seasons with minimal opportunities, he boasts a 3-1 record and a passer rating of 135.1.
• Statistics:
  • 79.9% completion rate
  • Six touchdown passes with no interceptions
  • Three rushing touchdowns on 42 attempts

Despite these impressive stats, questions loom regarding his transition to a starting role. The competition for Miami is fierce with potential negotiations underway, and other teams could bid for his services.

Looking at the Market

The Dolphins face key decisions, particularly concerning their current quarterback, Tua Tagovailoa. Teams like the New York Jets, Arizona Cardinals, and Pittsburgh Steelers could also impact Miami’s strategy. The Jets had previously invested a hefty two-year, $40 million deal in Justin Fields. Similar amounts may become the new normal as teams vie for available talent.

The Role of Coaching and Strategy

Bobby Slowik, the Dolphins’ retained pass game coordinator, along with Hackett’s offensive knowledge, can set Miami on the right path. Their experience with the west coast offense may prove beneficial as they develop potential quarterbacks, including Willis.

Ultimately, the success of Miami’s quarterback development and strategy will depend on effective execution and responsive planning. The coming weeks will be critical as they navigate these pivotal decisions.