Dalot Could Face Red Card in European Matches

Concerns have arisen regarding the possibility of Diogo Dalot facing a red card in upcoming European matches. This follows an examination of crucial decisions made in recent games involving similar challenges.

The Context of Dalot’s Challenge

A controversial decision during a match has drawn parallels to past instances where yellow cards were deemed appropriate. Notably, in a game between Chelsea and Tottenham last April, referee Craig Pawson ruled on a challenge made by Pape Matar Sarr against Moises Caicedo. Sarr made contact with Caicedo’s knee, which led to a VAR review, upheld by referee Jarred Gillett.

Review Process and Outcomes

• Gillett advised Pawson that the incident was reckless, not excessive force.
• Pawson subsequently issued a yellow card to Sarr rather than a red.

The decision was influenced by the nature of the challenge, which, while harmful, did not meet the threshold for a red card. Gillett and Pawson both mentioned that the contact appeared light, only creating a “glancing” blow.

Implications for Diogo Dalot

In contrast, Dalot’s situation is creating its own controversy. His straight-leg challenge is seen as an indicator of more significant force. Following similar reasoning, the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMO) head Howard Webb supported the yellow card decision. He noted that sending Dalot off would have been incorrect since the challenge did not involve excessive force. Webb stated, “It’s reckless contact, so a yellow card is appropriate.”

Key Comparisons

• Sarr’s challenge led to a VAR review and a goal disqualification with no major outcry for a red card.
• Conversely, the current situation around Dalot has raised eyebrows, potentially influencing future match outcomes.

Dalot’s challenge is compared to Curtis Jones’ red card in September 2023 against Yves Bissouma, which still resonates with Liverpool fans as an unjust decision. The key takeaway from these incidents reflects how each challenge’s circumstances play a crucial role in referee decisions during critical match moments.

Conclusion

As Diogo Dalot prepares for potential European matches, the scrutiny surrounding his challenges highlights the ongoing discussions around referee consistency and VAR intervention. Supporters will be watching closely, eager to see how similar situations are adjudicated in the future.