Newcastle vs Everton: Late Thierno Barry Winner Seals 3-2 Away Win at St James’ Park

Everton snatched a dramatic 3-2 victory over Newcastle on Saturday, Feb. 28, 2026 (ET), with substitute Thierno Barry scoring almost immediately after Newcastle thought it had rescued a point. The result deepens Newcastle’s poor home run and boosts Everton’s push up the Premier League table, while also adding another chapter to a rivalry that rarely lacks edge.

Played at a frenetic pace and packed with momentum swings, Newcastle vs Everton turned on two late moments: Jacob Murphy’s 82nd-minute equaliser for the hosts, and Barry’s swift response that silenced St James’ Park and sent the travelling support into celebration.

Newcastle vs Everton: How the Match Unfolded

Everton struck first and twice led on the day, combining direct play with sharp second-ball reactions inside the box. Newcastle, meanwhile, showed fight and flashes of quality but were repeatedly punished for defensive gaps at key moments.

The opener arrived in the first half when Everton capitalised from a set-piece situation, before Newcastle replied through a deflected effort that lifted the crowd and seemed to settle the home side. Everton regained the lead soon after, finishing a rebound chance to restore their advantage heading toward the break.

After halftime, Newcastle pressed for parity, increasing tempo and attacking width. Everton absorbed pressure, defended deeper for stretches, and relied on goalkeeper Jordan Pickford to keep their lead intact until the late drama.

Key Moments and Goals

The closing stages delivered the match’s defining sequence: Newcastle finally found a route back into the game, only to lose control of it again within minutes.

Pickford’s late stop in stoppage time preserved the result, denying Newcastle a dramatic second equaliser and underlining Everton’s resilience in away fixtures this season.

What the Result Means for Everton

For Everton, this was a statement win: three points earned in a hostile stadium, with an away performance built on composure under pressure and ruthless timing in front of goal. The Toffees have increasingly looked comfortable on the road, and this Newcastle - Everton result strengthens their grip on the upper half and keeps European qualification ambitions alive entering March.

The biggest positive was how Everton managed key phases. They took early control with a set-piece goal, responded immediately after conceding, and — most importantly — had the emotional stability to strike back instantly after the late equaliser. That ability to reset quickly has been a defining trait of teams that finish strong.

Barry’s cameo also gives Everton a timely attacking boost. Goals from the bench can swing seasons, and this one may be remembered as a turning point if Everton’s climb continues.

What the Loss Says About Newcastle

For Newcastle, the defeat will sting because the fightback seemed to have done the hard part. The equaliser at 82 minutes should have at least guaranteed a point. Instead, Newcastle conceded within a minute, highlighting a recurring issue: managing transitions and staying compact after emotional surges.

The match also extended a worrying pattern at St James’ Park, where Newcastle have struggled to close out tight games. Newcastle’s attacking threats arrived in waves, but the side lacked the calm defensive control needed after scoring. The overall performance showed spirit, yet the outcome reinforces the sense of a team stuck in a frustrating loop — good moments undone by costly lapses.

Everton, Newcastle, and the Bigger Premier League Picture

Newcastle vs Everton mattered beyond the 90 minutes because it directly reshaped the mid-table race. Everton’s win nudges them further ahead in the contest for higher placement and potential European spots, while Newcastle’s drop adds pressure with fixtures piling up in a crowded calendar.

For fans in the U.S., UK, Canada, and Australia following the Premier League, this match was a reminder that the league’s most compelling drama often comes outside the title chase. Teams battling for places from the top half to the mid-table pack are separated by fine margins — and a 72-second swing like the one that decided Newcastle - Everton can change the mood of an entire season.

Newcastle will now need a response quickly to halt the slide, while Everton leave Tyneside with a belief-building win and fresh momentum heading into the next round of fixtures.