Top 10 High-Risk, High-Reward Prospects in 2026 NFL Draft
The 2026 NFL Draft is shaping up to be intriguing, with numerous prospects heralded as high-risk, high-reward selections. This year, teams may face tough choices due to a lack of obvious elite talent. While some players showcase immense potential, significant concerns could affect their draft stock.
Top 10 High-Risk, High-Reward Prospects in the 2026 NFL Draft
Here’s a closer look at the ten prospects who embody this boom-or-bust mentality in the upcoming draft.
1. Arvell Reese – LB, Ohio State
Projected as the No. 2 overall pick, Arvell Reese poses significant uncertainty regarding his position in the NFL. Many view him as a versatile linebacker or edge defender. Despite his athleticism, his 13% pass-rush win rate this season raises questions about his transition to the next level.
2. Jordyn Tyson – WR, Arizona State
Jordyn Tyson’s PFF receiving grade of 89.5 ranks him among the top in the Power Four. However, his extensive injury history, including a torn ACL and missed games at Colorado, casts doubt on his durability. His health will be crucial in determining whether he can be a franchise No. 1 receiver.
3. Jermod McCoy – CB, Tennessee
Jermod McCoy demonstrated promise with an 89.6 PFF coverage grade. Unfortunately, like Tyson, he faced serious injury setbacks, missing the entirety of the 2025 season due to a torn ACL. His performance at the NFL Combine will be vital to confirming his draft position.
4. Keldric Faulk – EDGE, Auburn
Keldric Faulk is an elite run defender with an 89.2 PFF run-defense grade. However, his pass-rushing capabilities are less impressive, with a pass-rush win rate that places him in the lower ranks nationally. Teams must weigh his strengths against the lack of production in pass rushing.
5. Kenyon Sadiq – TE, Oregon
Kenyon Sadiq could be the fifth tight end selected in the first round over four years. While he offers significant potential as a separator and blocker, his PFF receiving grade is below that of recent first-round picks, necessitating improvement before entering the league.
6. Kadyn Proctor – OT, Alabama
Kadyn Proctor has shown promise, posting an 86.1 PFF grade. Yet, his struggles with speed rushers due to his size raise questions about his ability to succeed as a long-term tackle. Some speculate he may need to transition to guard.
7. Cashius Howell – EDGE, Texas A&M
Coming in at 6-foot-2 and 248 pounds, Cashius Howell’s impressive pass-rushing numbers, including a PFF grade above 90.0 for three consecutive years, make him an attractive option. Concerns about his size could impact his effectiveness against the run.
8. Ty Simpson – QB, Alabama
Ty Simpson is acknowledged as the second-best quarterback in this draft and shone during his time as Alabama’s starter. Although he excels under specific conditions, his struggles when pressured indicate a need for further development before stepping into a starting role.
9. Caleb Banks – DI, Florida
Caleb Banks is a noted pass-rusher with a pressure rate of 12%, ranking him among the top defensive tackles. However, injuries limited him in the previous season, and concerns over his run-defense ability linger, presenting a risk for teams considering a first-round selection.
10. Zachariah Branch – WR, Georgia
Zachariah Branch emerged as a top-50 pick following a transfer from USC. He posted an impressive 82.0 PFF grade and highlighted his playmaking ability. Nevertheless, questions persist about how his transition to the NFL will unfold, given his tendency to perform in limited depth of target situations.
As teams prepare for the 2026 NFL Draft, these prospects represent both significant potential and notable risks. Each player’s health, performance, and adaptability will be crucial in navigating the draft landscape.
