Derek Carr’s Potential Return: Exploring Options with the Saints

Derek Carr may be considering a return to the NFL after a potential retirement. The New Orleans Saints currently hold his rights, so any team interested in Carr would need to negotiate a trade. This situation mirrors the Saints’ recent trade of former coach Sean Payton to the Denver Broncos.

Derek Carr’s Options with the Saints

Carr’s recovery from a shoulder injury has sparked discussions about his playing future. If he decides to return, various teams may be in the market for a quarterback. The possibility of Carr linking up with a new team raises several key questions.

Potential Suitors for Derek Carr

There could be six to eight teams seeking new starting quarterbacks this offseason. However, not all of them are viable options for Carr. Here are three teams to consider:

• Minnesota Vikings: With a strong offense and talented players, the Vikings could be a good fit. Coach Kevin O’Connell’s expertise may align well with Carr’s skills.
• Pittsburgh Steelers: If Aaron Rodgers retires, the Steelers will look for a new quarterback. Their front office has connections to the Saints, which could facilitate a trade.
• New York Jets: Previously interested in Carr, the Jets now need a solid quarterback option. Their performance and coach’s job security rely heavily on their choice.

Expected Compensation for a Trade

The Saints received valuable picks when they traded Sean Payton, but a similar return for Carr is unlikely. Given the uncertainty surrounding Carr’s health and recent performance, potential compensation could look different.

Past Trade Comparisons

Examining previous trades can provide insight into what may happen with Carr:

• 2008, Brett Favre: The Packers traded Favre to the Jets for a conditional fourth-rounder.
• 2013, Carson Palmer: Palmer netted a first-round pick when moved from the Raiders to the Cardinals.
• 2020, Rob Gronkowski: The Patriots traded Gronkowski and a seventh-round pick to the Bucs for a fourth-rounder.

These examples illustrate that while quarterbacks can command a premium, the actual returns vary significantly. As Carr prepares for his next steps, teams will carefully evaluate their options.

Conclusion

Derek Carr’s potential return raises numerous questions. The Saints control his rights, which complicates the trade market. As the offseason approaches, both Carr and interested teams will need to navigate this landscape carefully.