New Hampshire Panel Deliberates Vaccine Bill Disputes
The discussion surrounding vaccine mandates in New Hampshire has intensified amid the implications of the COVID-19 pandemic. Recently, the Health, Human Services, and Elderly Affairs Committee convened to review bill HB 1811. This legislation aims to abolish vaccination requirements for children in public schools and related institutions.
Key Provisions of Bill HB 1811
HB 1811 seeks to prevent any political body in New Hampshire from enforcing vaccination mandates. The bill has sparked considerable debate, drawing a significant crowd to the recent hearing. Both advocates and detractors expressed their views, particularly regarding the role of pharmaceutical companies and government authority.
Current Vaccination Requirements in New Hampshire
- New Hampshire currently mandates vaccinations for nine specific diseases in public school children.
- Exemptions are allowed for medical and religious reasons.
Arguments For and Against the Bill
During the hearing, several medical professionals voiced their anxiety over the potential consequences of relaxing vaccine mandates. Experts warned of a possible resurgence of nearly eradicated diseases, including measles and polio. Dr. Benjamin Chan, the state epidemiologist, highlighted that vaccines have considerably decreased disease prevalence since they were first introduced in the 1880s.
On the opposing side, Representative Matt Drew, who sponsors the bill, contended that existing mandates diminish public trust. He criticized what he termed the coercive nature of vaccination policies, asserting that they compromise informed consent. Drew described the current vaccination advocacy as a “vaccine religion,” which he believes undermines personal choice.
Legislative Context
In recent changes, the New Hampshire House and Senate have gained the authority to determine mandated vaccinations, a shift from the previous system that placed this responsibility with the Department of Health and Human Services. Additionally, a new proposal aims to remove hepatitis B from the list of required vaccinations.
Upcoming Actions
The Health, Human Services, and Elderly Affairs Committee is anticipated to offer recommendations on HB 1811 next Wednesday. Following this, the bill may progress to the full House for further deliberation.
