Chris Sutton Confirms Everton Penalty Ruling Amid David Moyes’ Protests

Chris Sutton defended the match officials after Everton’s appeals for a spot-kick were turned down. The incident occurred early in the Merseyside derby on 19 April 2026. Filmogaz.com reported the showpiece clash and subsequent reactions later that day.

Penalty decision and reaction

Everton felt they should have had a penalty when Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall went down in the box. Curtis Jones was marking Dewsbury-Hall at the time. The referee did not award a foul, and VAR did not call for a pitchside review.

Chris Sutton said the contact looked shoulder-to-shoulder from his vantage. He noted Curtis Jones recovered well and that there was little to suggest a clear foul. The former striker therefore backed the officials over Everton’s protests.

Response from David Moyes

David Moyes made his frustration clear on the touchline and during the game. Everton players also appealed strongly at the moment. The manager maintained the challenge warranted a penalty.

Key moments after the decision

Everton’s frustration continued soon after the non-call. Iliman Ndiaye had a goal disallowed for offside in the buildup. Minutes later, Mohamed Salah opened the scoring for Liverpool.

Salah converted after being set up by Cody Gakpo. The shot beat Jordan Pickford and put Liverpool ahead. That strike proved decisive in the first half momentum.

Summary and context

• Match: Merseyside derby, 19 April 2026.
• Controversy: Dewsbury-Hall challenge on Curtis Jones led to appeals.
• VAR: No recommendation for on-field review.
• Other incidents: Iliman Ndiaye goal ruled out for offside.
• Goal: Mohamed Salah scored, assisted by Cody Gakpo.

The debate centred on interpretation of contact and advantage. Chris Sutton supported the Everton penalty ruling being dismissed despite David Moyes’ protests. The decision remains a talking point after the derby.