USA Hockey Changes Eligibility Policy, Sparks Outrage from First Openly Trans Player
USA Hockey’s recently revised eligibility policy has ignited significant controversy, particularly from Harrison Browne, the first openly transgender professional hockey player. Browne’s criticism highlights his belief that the policy is inherently discriminatory against transgender athletes and poses risks to their participation in the sport.
Overview of USA Hockey’s New Eligibility Policy
In November 2025, USA Hockey implemented a new Participant Eligibility Policy, intended to replace its 2019 regulations regarding transgender athletes. The updated guidelines will take effect following the USA Hockey national Championships in April 2026. This policy aims to maintain sex-based categories in certain competitions.
Browne’s Reaction to the Policy
Browne, who played in the National Women’s Hockey League (NWHL) from 2015 to 2018, expressed his disappointment through social media. He stated that the policy effectively bars transgender individuals from participating in certain settings—including women’s recreational leagues—especially those who have undergone hormone therapy.
Key Highlights of the Policy Change
- The new policy retains sex-based categories for specific competitions.
- It clarifies that participation in programs restricted by sex is determined by an athlete’s biological sex at birth.
- A female athlete assigned at birth may not compete in female-restricted programs if she has received male hormone therapy.
This approach aims to ensure fairness within women’s sports and addresses concerns about competition integrity. Nevertheless, Browne argues it limits opportunities for many athletes seeking a safe space to compete.
Concerns About Trans Inclusion in Sports
The debate extends beyond hockey. Following the passing of the “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports” executive order, several athletic organizations, including the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), have similarly adjusted their policies regarding transgender athletes.
| Organization | Policy Summary |
|---|---|
| USA Hockey | Retains sex-based categories for certain programs; participation determined by biological sex. |
| NCAA | Prohibits trans-identified males from women’s teams but allows practice participation. |
Growing Opposition and Statistics
Critics of policies permitting transgender athletes in women’s sports cite competitive fairness, alleging that trans women have an unfair advantage. A report from the advocacy group Concerned Women for America indicated that trans-identifying male athletes have won over 1,900 gold medals in women-only events.
As the discourse around gender identity and athletics evolves, Browne’s assertions and USA Hockey’s policy shift are set to spur further discussions about inclusivity, fairness, and the future landscape of sports.
