Review: Jay Duplass’ ‘See You When I See You’ Delivers Uneven Tragicomedy

Jay Duplass’ latest film, “See You When I See You,” presents an engaging tragicomedy that captures the struggles of young adulthood. It follows a young man named Aaron, played by Cooper Raiff, as he navigates life after a family tragedy. The film is based on the memoir of screenwriter Adam Cayton-Holland, centering around the emotional fallout from his sister’s suicide.

Plot Overview

The narrative introduces Aaron, who deflects serious topics with humor and is struggling with grief after the death of his sister, Leah. His journey begins with a scene at a taco truck, where he clumsily attempts to contact a therapist his sister’s type-A older sister, Emily, has found for him. However, the scene takes a comedic turn when a bird unexpectedly poops on his head.

Family Dynamics

The film delves into the complexities of Aaron’s family as they clear Leah’s apartment. Key characters include:

• Emily – Aaron’s older sister, portrayed by Lucy Boynton.
• Paige – Their mother, played by Hope Davis.
• Robert – Their father, depicted by David Duchovny.

This family grapples with whether to organize a funeral while each member navigates their grief differently. Robert and Emily favor a formal ceremony, while Paige and Aaron resist. The film effectively showcases their dysfunction and avoidance in dealing with the tragedy.

The Impact of Grief

Aaron works at a comedy-writing site he founded but often turns to alcohol as an escape. His family members display avoidance behaviors, highlighting the contradictions in their privileged lives amidst sorrow. The film powerfully portrays their struggles, including Robert’s controversial openness with clients about Leah’s suicide.

Therapy and Healing

A significant turning point for Aaron comes when he decides to reconnect with Camila, played by Ariela Barer. Their relationship offers both tension and support as Aaron confronts his past. The film shines in its second half when Aaron begins therapy sessions that explore his trauma and start his healing process.

Therapeutic Techniques

The therapy sessions are particularly noteworthy. They incorporate EMDR therapy, which helps Aaron revisit the traumatic day he found Leah’s body. This fresh approach provides insight into a common narrative trope of young men seeking help and showcases Aaron’s growth.

Conclusion

“See You When I See You” premiered at the 2026 Sundance Film Festival. Despite its flaws and moments of predictability, the film’s earnestness makes it a poignant exploration of grief and recovery. Its blend of humor and heartfelt moments ultimately leaves the audience with a sense of hope.

The film is currently seeking distribution in the U.S.