Pirates Consider Re-Signing Star Outfielder Andrew McCutchen
Andrew McCutchen, the veteran outfielder, has voiced his frustration over being unsigned as he approaches the 2026 season. His absence from PiratesFest sparked concern about his future with the Pittsburgh Pirates, where he has spent 12 of his 18 Major League seasons. McCutchen expressed a desire to engage with fans one last time if this season were to be his last.
Pittsburgh Pirates and McCutchen’s Future
In August, McCutchen stated his intention to return to the Pirates for another season, despite acknowledging a challenging year in 2025. He emphasized the need to demonstrate his ability to contribute effectively on the field. “I want to play a role, not just fill a spot,” he mentioned.
Performance Metrics
During the 2025 season, McCutchen had a batting average of .239 with 13 home runs over 551 plate appearances. His metrics translated to a 95 weighted runs created plus (wRC+), marking the second time in his career he fell below the league-average threshold. His walk rate was strong at 12.2%, though most of his Statcast numbers indicated average performance.
Team Dynamics and Management’s Perspective
Pirates General Manager Ben Cherington discussed McCutchen during PiratesFest, confirming their desire to maintain a positive relationship. However, he indicated the team is focusing on constructing a roster aimed at winning games. “We need to build a team that gives us the best chance to win,” Cherington noted.
- McCutchen’s previous seasons with the Pirates: 12 out of 18 years
- 2025 season stats: .239 batting average, 13 homers, 95 wRC+
- Current age: 39
Roster Changes and Positioning
The Pirates have signed Ryan O’Hearn, who is expected to take on a significant role at designated hitter. O’Hearn’s addition potentially complicates McCutchen’s chances of remaining in the lineup, as he may be limited to a part-time role against left-handed pitchers. The Pirates are also exploring other avenues to improve their offense.
McCutchen’s Legacy
As a franchise icon, the decision to part ways with McCutchen is delicate. Cherington and ownership likely prefer to avoid severing ties with him unless it becomes necessary. McCutchen’s return to the Pirates in 2023 was motivated by his desire to contribute to a future winning era. However, with seven consecutive losing seasons, Pittsburgh is still seeking to emerge from its rebuilding phase.
As of January 24, no substantial discussions regarding McCutchen’s contract have emerged. With Spring Training on the horizon, both parties have time to negotiate a potential deal.
