Catholic Leaders Condemn U.S. Foreign Policy

The leadership within the American Catholic Church has recently raised concerns about U.S. foreign policy. In a statement issued on a Monday in 2026, three prominent Catholic bishops voiced their apprehensions regarding America’s role in global affairs. Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, Cardinal Robert McElroy of Washington, and Cardinal Joseph Tobin of Newark emphasized that America’s moral stance in addressing global challenges is under scrutiny.

Catholic Leaders Critique U.S. Foreign Policy

The bishops’ statement, notable for its clarity and directness, does not mention President Trump by name. However, it symbolizes a significant escalation in criticism from the American Catholic Church toward the nation’s leadership. The statement reflects a sentiment of urgency for establishing a moral foundation in U.S. actions on the world stage, reminiscent of the world’s moral debates since the Cold War.

Key Issues Highlighted by the Cardinals

• Recent events in Venezuela, Ukraine, and Greenland raised crucial questions about military interventions.
• The cardinals advocate for a foreign policy where military action is a last resort.
• The bishops stress the importance of a diplomatic approach over any form of aggression.

In their discussions, the cardinals emphasized the rising global trend that favors domination through force rather than pursuing peace and freedom. Cardinal McElroy noted a shift away from post-World War II diplomatic consensus, which originally prioritized dialogue among nations.

Context of the Statement

This strong message was inspired by conversations during a recent gathering in Rome attended by the global body of cardinals. Their shared feelings of alarm focused on not only U.S. foreign policy but also the dismantling of the U.S. Agency for International Development, which has hindered foreign assistance to impoverished nations.

Pope Leo XIV’s Position

Pope Leo XIV, who succeeded Pope Francis in May 2025, has reiterated the need for diplomacy founded on peace. His criticisms toward aggression in international relations have echoed the sentiments expressed in the bishops’ statement. Although the pope has refrained from directly confronting President Trump, his advocacy for dialogue and support for marginalized groups has been clear.

The Moral Framework for Foreign Policy

The cardinals’ statement is reflective of Pope Leo’s vision, positioning itself as a moral compass for future American foreign policy. They warn that the rights of nations to self-determine their political futures are at risk amid increasing global conflicts.

Furthermore, the bishops called attention to various social issues, including the right to life and religious freedom, which they assert are foundational to human rights. They also criticized recent cuts to foreign aid, warning that these policies foster division and promote destructive actions.

The Impact on American Catholics

The three archbishops collectively represent nearly four million Catholics, encompassing over 550 parishes and numerous Catholic schools across the nation. Their call for a well-rounded foreign policy resonates with their constituents who view ethical leadership as integral to both faith and governance.

Ultimately, the call from Catholic leaders highlights a significant crossroads for U.S. foreign policy, urging a shift towards a more humane and morally sound approach as the global context evolves. As the landscape of international relations continues to shift, the American Catholic Church stands firm in advocating for peace and justice.