Nolan Arenado Trade Botched by Surprise Suitor Before Arizona Deal

Nolan Arenado’s trade saga has come to an end. The St. Louis Cardinals traded the illustrious third baseman to the Arizona Diamondbacks. This decision occurred after a prolonged period of speculation about his future. The trade focused on salary relief and included right-handed pitching prospect Jack Martinez.

Nolan Arenado Trade Details

The Cardinals faced significant challenges moving Arenado due to his disappointing 2025 season and the substantial salary owed to him. Despite these difficulties, the trade, finalized on a Tuesday, ultimately set the stage for Arenado’s new chapter in Arizona.

Surprising Interest from the San Diego Padres

In an unexpected turn of events, reports revealed that the San Diego Padres had shown interest in acquiring Arenado. Sources indicate that the Padres aimed to sign him as a first baseman, even though Manny Machado has a stronghold at third base.

Financial Constraints in Trade Negotiations

• The Padres were hesitant due to financial limitations, which impacted their negotiations.
• They were unwilling to absorb as much of Arenado’s contract as the Diamondbacks were.
• Arenado’s 2026 salary of $5 million and $6 million in 2027 seemed unaffordable for San Diego.

Market Value and Trade Implications

The market’s perception of Arenado’s value played a crucial role in this trade scenario. Many teams refrained from pursuing him, indicating a lack of confidence in his performance due to his contract situation.

FanGraphs evaluated Arenado as worth $7 million despite his down season, making his acquisition at a lower salary seem reasonable. However, the Padres’ reluctance to invest even a modest amount raised questions about their commitment to winning.

Arenado’s Preferences and Future Prospects

While the Diamondbacks landed Arenado, there were indications that he might have preferred a move to the Padres. His Southern California roots and the Padres’ roster had the potential to create a more competitive environment for the player.

Looking ahead, both teams face challenges as they aim to contend in the league. San Diego needs to address its roster gaps to compete effectively against the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2026, whereas Arizona benefits from adding a seasoned player like Arenado.