Judge Dismisses Trump’s $10B Lawsuit Against WSJ on Epstein Book Report
A federal judge in Florida has dismissed former President Donald Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal over allegations regarding a birthday card associated with Jeffrey Epstein. U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles delivered the ruling, stating that Trump’s claims fell short of proving actual malice.
Details of the Lawsuit
The lawsuit was filed in July 2022 after the Journal published a story suggesting that a birthday card sent to Epstein included a bizarre message from Trump. The card was purportedly part of a compilation for Epstein’s 50th birthday in 2003, and Trump was a known associate during that period.
Judge’s Findings
Judge Gayles concluded that the lawsuit did not adequately demonstrate that The Wall Street Journal acted with knowledge of falsehood or reckless disregard for truth. He noted that the publication had reached out to Trump and federal authorities prior to the story’s release, receiving a denial from Trump, no response from the Justice Department, and a refusal to comment from the FBI.
Card Controversy and Response
- The card reportedly featured a crude drawing and a typewritten note imagined as a conversation with Epstein.
- Trump’s legal team accused the paper of fabricating the card, which they maintain is a fake.
- A version of the card matching the Journal’s description surfaced later, released by Epstein’s estate.
Next Steps for Trump
Due to the ruling, which was made “without prejudice,” Trump has the option to refile his lawsuit. He has been given a two-week window to submit an amended complaint. A spokesperson from Trump’s team stated that he intends to follow the court’s guidance.
Reactions from Both Parties
Following the decision, a spokesperson for Dow Jones and Company, the publisher of The Wall Street Journal, expressed satisfaction with the ruling, emphasizing their commitment to accurate reporting.
Background on Trump and Epstein
Trump and Epstein had a friendship that lasted over a decade, ending in the early 2000s. Trump cited Epstein’s behavior, particularly concerning young women, as the reason for their fallout. In a recent congressional committee hearing, former President Bill Clinton mentioned a long-ago conversation with Trump regarding Epstein, recounting that Trump had enjoyed times with Epstein before their relationship soured over a real estate deal.
The Legacy of Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein, a financier with significant political connections, pleaded guilty to soliciting a minor in 2008. He died in jail in 2019 while awaiting trial for sex trafficking. Epstein’s criminal activities are said to have impacted over 1,000 women and girls.
Thus far, Trump has not faced charges related to Epstein and continues to deny any involvement in illicit activities associated with him.
