Cubs’ Caleb Thielbar Commits Error: Why Was Matt Shaw at First Base?
The Chicago Cubs faced a tough loss against the Pittsburgh Pirates, falling 4-3 after a critical error by reliever Caleb Thielbar in the 11th inning. This mistake allowed the deciding run to score, marking a painful chapter in the team’s ongoing struggles.
Cubs’ Caleb Thielbar Commits Error
Thielbar’s throwing error became the decisive moment of the game. After an intentional walk to O’Neil Cruz, Thielbar fielded a ball but inaccurately threw it, resulting in a score by ghost runner Nick Gonzales. “I work on that play every single day… it makes me sick,” Thielbar expressed after the game.
Matt Shaw’s Role at First Base
Adding to the Cubs’ troubles was the performance of first baseman Michael Busch, who was enduring a significant slump at the plate. Busch had not recorded a hit since April 1, leaving the team with a dilemma at first base. As the game progressed, manager Craig Counsell decided to replace Busch with Carson Kelly during a crucial moment.
- Busch’s batting average: .000 in his last 30 at-bats.
- Shaw played first base for the first time in his professional career.
- The Cubs left 16 men on base throughout the game.
Statistical Insights
Despite bringing in Shaw, the Cubs could not capitalize on scoring opportunities. In the ninth inning, Alex Bregman tied the game with a single, but Shaw ended up stranded on third base. Earlier, the team had left the bases loaded, showcasing their inability to convert opportunities into runs.
| Player | At Bats | Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Michael Busch | 3 | 0 hits, 2 strikeouts |
| Carson Kelly | 1 | Popped out |
| Matt Shaw | 1 | Stranded on third |
Looking Ahead
The Cubs are still seeking their first come-from-behind victory of the 2026 season. They need to address their execution and improve their offensive consistency. “We just gotta execute,” Bregman noted, emphasizing the team’s need for better performance in critical moments.
As for upcoming games, the Cubs have not announced their pitching rotation for the series against the Philadelphia Phillies. However, Javier Assad, Colin Rea, and Shota Imanaga are expected to pitch in that sequence.
