Quebec Probes Israeli Soldiers’ Speeches in Montreal Schools

Concerns have arisen in Quebec regarding Israeli soldiers addressing students in Montreal schools during the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict. Education Minister Sonia LeBel expressed alarm over the situation, labeling it “extremely concerning.” LeBel indicated that the government is currently reviewing the circumstances and will take “appropriate action” if warranted.

Background of the Situation

Reports by La Presse revealed that “active or former members of the Israel Defense Forces” conducted presentations in publicly funded Jewish schools, specifically Herzliah and Bialik in Côte-Saint-Luc, at least 14 times since the fall of 2023. LeBel was made aware of these occurrences last fall and has described them as troubling.

Political Reactions

Ruba Ghazal, the parliamentary leader of Quebec solidaire, voiced strong opposition, stating, “We are funding private, religious, faith-based schools with public Quebec money to indoctrinate students through people from Israel who have committed a genocide.” She emphasized that this is not acceptable in Quebec.

The Parti Québécois also condemned the situation. MNA Pascal Paradis stated, “Our schools should be sanctuaries where students can form their own opinions based on the Quebec government’s curriculum.” He stressed the importance of maintaining educational spaces free from external influences.

In contrast, the Quebec Liberal Party took a more measured approach. MNA Madwa-Nika Cadet insisted that thorough verifications are necessary. She noted, “If it turns out that their obligations weren’t respected, there are already consequences provided for under the Private Education Act.”

Next Steps in the Investigation

The minister responsible for secularism, Jean-François Roberge, refrained from commenting on the issue. As the investigation continues, the education ministry remains under scrutiny for ensuring that Quebec’s educational environments uphold neutrality and are devoid of political or religious propaganda.

• Education Minister: Sonia LeBel
• Locations of Concern: Herzliah and Bialik schools, Côte-Saint-Luc
• Number of Presentations: At least 14 since fall 2023
• Political Leaders:
  • Ruba Ghazal (Quebec solidaire)
  • Pascal Paradis (Parti Québécois)
  • Madwa-Nika Cadet (Quebec Liberal Party)

The investigation will critically assess the appropriateness of these presentations in educational settings. Ensuring the integrity of Quebec’s school system remains a top priority for the provincial government.