Google Denies Allegations of Stealing David Greene’s Voice
David Greene, a prominent radio host, is currently involved in a legal dispute with Google. He alleges that the technology giant appropriated his voice for its NotebookLM AI tool without permission. Greene, known for co-hosting NPR’s Morning Edition and hosting the Left, Right, & Center podcast, became aware of the situation through a former colleague.
Details of the Lawsuit
The lawsuit was officially filed on January 23 in California. In his complaint, Greene states that Google aimed to replicate his unique voice, honed over years of experience in radio broadcasting. He alleges that the tech company sought to create synthetic audio mimicking his delivery, cadence, and persona.
Legal Grounds for the Complaint
- Violation of California’s right to publicity law, concerning unauthorized use of an individual’s likeness.
- Claims of unfair competition under California law.
- Allegations that Google benefited unlawfully from Greene’s identifiable vocal characteristics.
Greene expressed his shock upon discovering the existence of NotebookLM, which autogenerates podcasts, comparing the experience to a significant violation of his personal rights.
Google’s Response
In response to the allegations, Google has firmly denied any wrongdoing. Spokesperson José Castañeda emphasized that NotebookLM’s voice features are created using a professional actor hired specifically for this purpose. He described Greene’s claims as “baseless.”
AI and Copyright Controversies
The use of voices and likenesses in AI-generated content has stirred substantial debate. In 2024, OpenAI faced backlash for its AI-powered voice, named Sky, which allegedly resembled that of actress Scarlett Johansson without her permission. Johansson, alongside other major artists, has campaigned against unauthorized use of personal likenesses in AI models.
The ongoing legal discussions highlight a growing concern within the tech and creative industries regarding the ethical use of personal attributes in AI development.
Conclusion
The allegations brought by David Greene against Google underscore a significant issue in the realm of artificial intelligence and copyright law. As technology evolves, the importance of securing permission for the use of personal voices and likenesses in AI remains critical.
