Billie Eilish Faces Backlash for ‘Stolen Land’ Speech at Grammys

Billie Eilish has recently faced criticism over her comments regarding “stolen land” during her Grammy acceptance speech. The backlash intensified after a Native American tribe claimed her mansion, valued at $3 million, was constructed on their ancestral territory.

Details of the Grammy Speech

At the Grammy Awards held on Sunday, Eilish won the prestigious Song of the Year. During her speech, she condemned former President Donald Trump’s immigration policies, particularly the actions of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. Eilish declared, “no one is illegal on stolen land,” captivating the audience but igniting controversy.

Tongva Tribe’s Response

The Tongva tribe, the Indigenous peoples native to the Los Angeles Basin and Southern Channel Islands, responded to Eilish’s comments. They stated that her property resides on their historical homeland. A spokesperson for the tribe expressed disappointment, urging that she should have acknowledged their specific plight.

Statement from the Tongva Tribe

• “Eilish has not contacted our tribe directly regarding her property.”
• They appreciate when celebrities highlight historical injustices but prefer explicit references.
• “The greater Los Angeles Basin remains Gabrieleno Tongva territory.”

Political Reactions

The controversy escalated as political figures joined in, suggesting Eilish should reconsider her stance. Republican Senator Mike Lee called for her to “immediately” return her land to Native Americans. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis questioned the authenticity of her claims about “stolen land,” suggesting she should forfeit her mansion. Political commentator Brandon Tatum also proposed that individuals should occupy her property, arguing it is “stolen land.”

Historical Context

The history between the Tongva tribe and land ownership is complex. In 1769, members of the tribe were forced to work for Spanish settlers, which led to significant displacement. In 1848, when California was ceded to the United States after the Mexican-American War, the tribe was not consulted. Their land was transferred without their consent, a pattern that has echoed throughout history.

As discussions around Eilish’s comments continue, the broader conversation about Indigenous rights and historical injustices remains a critical topic in American society.