Traffic Delays Stall $9M McDonald’s and Aldi Development Plan
The proposed $9 million development plan for a McDonald’s drive-through and an Aldi supermarket in Pinjarra has been temporarily stalled due to traffic concerns. The Metro Outer Development Assessment Panel met on January 13 to review the proposal, which is located on the southern side of Pinjarra Road. Following discussions, the panel voted unanimously to defer the decision for up to 120 days.
Development Details
The development aims to include various components:
- Aldi supermarket: 1,100 sqm with a 55 sqm liquor store
- McDonald’s: Drive-through and seating for 46 customers
- Site area: 10,029 sqm, primarily vacant except for an unused heritage-listed Masonic hall
Previous Approvals and Traffic Concerns
This site has a history of development proposals. In 2015, the Shire of Murray approved a commercial project with four buildings, but it was never implemented. A subsequent application for a drive-through liquor store in 2017 was denied.
Under the current shire’s precinct structure plan, drive-through facilities are not permitted in the Pinjarra town center. Although the panel was advised to eliminate the drive-through option, it decided to keep it in while gathering further information on its potential impact.
Impact on Traffic
Main Roads WA expressed worries about the development’s access points on George Street and Pinjarra Road, recommending a left-out only on George Street. A report indicated the McDonald’s could result in nearly 1,700 vehicle movements daily, which could disrupt local traffic flow, especially around schools and bus stops.
Community Response and Panel Discussion
During the panel meeting, various members voiced their concerns. Presiding member Karen Hyde suggested more analysis before removing the drive-through. She acknowledged existing McDonald’s outlets in Western Australia without drive-throughs, questioning their necessity for this location.
Joshua Carmody from Planning Solutions argued that local planning objectives were being met with the proposed design. However, panel members expressed discomfort with the vehicle-centric nature of the proposal, especially considering the high volume of heavy haulage vehicles along George Street.
Landowner’s Viewpoint
Landowner James McClements emphasized that the Aldi and McDonald’s development would attract essential investment and invigorate the area. He stated that the combined development would enhance the Pinjarra Junction shopping center and the town center.
Community Support and Concerns
The proposal drew significant public attention, with a total of 364 submissions received during its advertisement period. Notably:
- Support for Aldi: 330 submissions
- Support for McDonald’s: 272 submissions
Despite the strong backing, residents raised concerns about the sites’ proximity to schools, impacts on local businesses, and traffic implications.
The future of the development remains uncertain as the panel continues to evaluate the implications of the proposed McDonald’s and Aldi project amidst valid traffic concerns.
