Does Hilary Duff’s New Song Reflect Her Relationship with Sister Haylie?

Hilary Duff has recently returned to the music scene with a new song titled “We Don’t Talk.” This track debuted during her first headlining concert in 2008 and delves into her complicated relationship with her sister, Haylie Duff. Fans have speculated that the song expresses a longing for reconnection after years of distance between the two.

Exploring the Lyrics

The lyrics of “We Don’t Talk” provide insight into Hilary’s feelings towards her sister. In the pre-chorus, she sings:

• “’Cause we come from the same home, the same blood”
• “A different combination, but the same mom”

These lines suggest that the song might indeed be reflecting her relationship with Haylie. Hilary’s uncertainty about their estrangement is evident in her lyrics, where she questions:

• “I’m not sure when it happened”
• “If I did something different, would you feel something different?”

Past Collaborations

Haylie has been a significant presence in Hilary’s career. She opened for Hilary in 2004 during the Most Wanted Tour and co-starred with her in the film “Material Girls.” However, the sisters have not been publicly photographed together since 2019, leading fans to wonder about the state of their relationship.

Recent Public Appearances

Discussions about their bond have surfaced sporadically. In early 2020, Haylie commented on Hilary’s marriage to Matthew Koma, calling it “a really special day,” though it was unclear if she attended the wedding. The sisters shared minimal public interactions afterward, with Haylie reflecting on preparing Hilary’s favorite Thanksgiving meal in 2020, yet remaining largely quiet about their relationship since then.

Personal Reflections

Hilary has kept her personal relationships private, but her new song offers a glimpse into her emotions. In a 2025 interview, she mentioned how she connected with fans through shared life experiences, stating:

• “We have gone through a lot of the same things — complicated relationships, anxiety, and family drama.”
• “Finally, I felt safe enough to open that part of myself up again.”

“We Don’t Talk” represents a heartfelt exploration of familial ties and the complexities of sibling relationships, particularly between Hilary and Haylie Duff. As fans eagerly await more details, they continue to speculate on the impact of this new music on sisterly bonds.