Top Love Islanders with Most Appearances on the Reality Show
Love Island: All Stars has returned for its third season, bringing back several familiar faces from past seasons. Notably, Scott van-der-Sluis made history by appearing for the fourth time in the franchise, alongside Samie Elishi, who is now a three-time Islander. This article highlights the top Islanders with multiple appearances on the show, showcasing their journeys and impact.
Top Love Islanders with Most Appearances
1. Casey O’Gorman
Casey O’Gorman holds the record for most Love Island appearances, totaling four. His journey spans:
- Love Island season 9 (2023)
- Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024)
- Love Island: All Stars season 2 (2025)
- Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
Casey first gained attention in season 9, where he left with Rosie after a budding romance. His second All Stars appearance saw him win the show alongside Gabby Allen.
2. Scott van-der-Sluis
Scott van-der-Sluis has also made four appearances:
- Love Island season 10 (2023)
- Love Island USA season 5 (2023)
- Love Island Games season 1 (2023)
- Love Island: All Stars season 3 (2026)
Scott’s journey included a brief relationship with Catherine Agbaje in season 10 and another stint in Love Island USA. He plans to exit the franchise after this latest appearance.
3. Toby Aromolaran
Like his peers, Toby Aromolaran has appeared four times:
- Love Island season 7 (2021)
- Love Island Games season 1 (2023)
- Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024)
- Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
Toby’s initial fame came from a strong relationship with Chloe Burrows, and he has since made multiple appearances without claiming a title.
4. Gabby Allen
Gabby Allen completed her third appearance with:
- Love Island season 3 (2017)
- Love Island: All Stars season 2 (2025)
- Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
She rose to fame in season three with Marcel Somerville and formed a successful partnership with Casey in All Stars.
5. Georgia Steel
Georgia Steel has also made three appearances:
- Love Island season 4 (2018)
- Love Island Games season 1 (2023)
- Love Island: All Stars season 1 (2024)
Her first season showcased her loyalty, which became a notable highlight. She subsequently paired with Toby in the All Stars series.
6. Lucinda Strafford
Lucinda Strafford has participated in three editions:
- Love Island season 7 (2021)
- Love Island Australia (2023)
- Love Island Games (2025)
Lucinda’s international journey includes a strong finish in Australia and a win in Love Island Games, although she and her partner split thereafter.
7. Samie Elishi
Samie Elishi recently marked her third appearance:
- Love Island season 9 (2023)
- Love Island: All Stars season 2 (2025)
- Love Island: All Stars season 3 (2026)
After a notable stint in season 9 and a brief stay in the previous All Stars, she aims to make a significant impact in the current season.
The world of Love Island continues to fascinate fans, particularly with the return of these beloved characters. As the reality show progresses, viewers eagerly anticipate what the future holds for these Islanders.
