U.S. Archbishops Critique Morality of American Foreign Policy: NPR

The senior Roman Catholic leaders in the United States have expressed significant concerns regarding the nation’s foreign policy. This critique was articulated through a formal statement issued on May 9, 2025, by Cardinals Blase Cupich of Chicago, Joseph Tobin of Newark, and Robert McElroy of Washington. Although they refrained from naming specific individuals, their remarks were clearly directed toward the previous Trump administration.

Archbishops’ Concerns Over American Foreign Policy

The archbishops pointed out critical moral issues linked to U.S. actions abroad. They stated that America’s role in combating global evils, promoting human rights, and supporting religious liberty is currently under scrutiny. The statement emphasized that achieving sustainable peace has become entangled in partisan politics, which could lead to harmful policies.

• Moral Questions Raised: The archbishops articulated concerns about the moral implications of military actions.
• Key Global Hotspots: They highlighted situations in Venezuela, Ukraine, and Greenland as pivotal issues requiring careful consideration.
• Focus on Human Dignity: The call was for a foreign policy grounded in respect for human life, religious freedom, and human dignity.

Citation of Pope Leo XIV’s Address

The archbishops were inspired by a recent speech from Pope Leo XIV addressed to ambassadors at the Holy See. In this address, delivered on January 9, the Pope lamented the diminishing role of multilateral diplomacy and warned against the rise of militaristic approaches to global conflicts.

Pope Leo XIV stated, “A diplomacy that promotes dialogue… is being replaced by one based on force.” This shift poses risks to the rule of law, essential for peaceful coexistence.

Pastoral Responsibility

Cardinal Cupich underscored the duty of church leaders to guide their communities. He noted, “As pastors, we cannot remain silent while decisions jeopardize the lives of millions.” The statements from the U.S. archbishops reflect a commitment to apply the teachings of the Pope in addressing both national and international issues.

As the discussion continues, the criticism from the American cardinals raises essential questions about the ethical responsibilities underlying U.S. foreign policy and its broader implications for human rights and peace initiatives globally.