Borden-Carleton Gas Station Project Approved Amid Strong Opposition
Approval has been granted for a fourth gas station in Borden-Carleton, sparking strong opposition among local residents and officials. The Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC) sanctioned the project, which is led by D.P. Murphy Group of Companies. This decision has raised significant concerns regarding the impact on the community.
Borden-Carleton Gas Station Project Overview
D.P. Murphy plans to develop a 24-hour Irving gas station, a Tim Hortons, a convenience store, and two retail spaces. The project will be situated near the Confederation Bridge, a strategic location for traffic flow.
Opposition to the Development
Local officials are voicing their discontent. Jamie Fox, former MLA and ex-owner of the Esso gas station, expressed disappointment over the IRAC’s decision, arguing that the need for an additional gas station is unfounded. Fox highlighted that three existing stations adequately serve both local residents and travelers.
- Jamie Fox criticized IRAC for lacking understanding of the local gas market.
- He cited a lack of substantial traffic increases and advancements in fuel efficiency as reasons against the need for another gas station.
Current MLA and P.E.I. Green Party Leader Matt MacFarlane also opposed the approval. He noted that over 400 letters and two petitions with more than 1,000 signatures were submitted against the project. MacFarlane stated, “It was unanimous. Everyone was opposed to the idea.”
Community Impact and Business Concerns
Chad Ceretti, owner of a nearby grocery and hardware store, expressed his concerns about the future of his business if a fourth gas station opens. He indicated that the overwhelming community opposition feels unaccounted for in IRAC’s decision-making.
- Ceretti and other local gas station owners fear for their livelihoods.
- Local sentiment suggests that the project could negatively impact existing businesses.
The Path Forward for D.P. Murphy
D.P. Murphy remains optimistic and believes that all four gas stations can coexist in the area. They are currently seeking development permits from the Town of Borden-Carleton and finalizing a petroleum supply agreement with Irving.
While acknowledging the opposition, D.P. Murphy’s legal counsel, Cullen Mullally, highlighted the potential increase in traffic from the recent toll reduction on the Confederation Bridge. “Our research shows that bridge crossing numbers correlate strongly with regional gas sales,” he noted.
As the situation unfolds, there are discussions of a potential appeal against IRAC’s decision. Local leaders continue to advocate for the interests of the community, emphasizing the necessity for regulatory decisions to prioritize public welfare over business proposals.
