Indiana Woman Accused in Murder Plot Orders Hit on Best Friend

Authorities in Freetown, Indiana, are dealing with a shocking murder plot that emerged following a burglary incident on September 19, 2023. The case revolves around Marsha Allen and her daughter, Ashley Jones, who are implicated in the death of Harold Allen, Marsha’s husband.

Burglary Leads to Murder Investigation

The investigation began when Marsha Allen reported a burglary at her home. She recognized one of the suspects as Steven White, a close friend of her daughter. Allen told police that White had been captured on security cameras during the break-in.

Shortly after the burglary, authorities located White, who confessed to the crime. However, he also dropped a bombshell by claiming that Marsha Allen was responsible for her husband’s death.

Details of the Murder Allegations

Harold Allen had died in 2022 following a decline in health that was initially attributed to cardiac issues. White alleged that Marsha had poisoned her husband using ethylene glycol, commonly found in antifreeze, added to a root beer float.

Text messages between Marsha and Ashley indicated they had attempted to kill Harold multiple times using various poisons. Investigators believe Marsha served the lethal drink to her husband on December 19, 2022.

Tragic Outcome and Legal Developments

Just a month after the burglary, police questioned Marsha Allen. She vehemently denied any involvement in her husband’s passing. Tragically, hours later, she took her own life. This left Ashley Jones to face the consequences alone.

Ashley Jones was subsequently charged with her father’s murder and was placed in Jackson County Jail. During her incarceration, she allegedly provided a “kill list” to a fellow inmate, targeting individuals believed to have knowledge about her family’s dark past.

• First on the list was Steven White, the burglar.
• The list is thought to contain names of potential witnesses.

Investigators’ Insights

Jackson County Sheriff’s Department officials expressed concern over the implications of the kill list. Detective Adam Nicholson stated that he believed Ashley would have harmed those individuals if given the chance.

In August 2025, Ashley Jones accepted a plea deal, pleading guilty to attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder. She received a 50-year prison sentence for her actions. In contrast, Steven White was sentenced to three and a half years for his involvement in the burglary.

This case highlights the intricate layers of betrayal and tragedy within families, leaving a lasting impact on the community of Freetown, Indiana.