Ian McKellen Critiques Hamnet’s Plot, Predicts Oscar Triumph
Sir Ian McKellen, a renowned actor with extensive experience in Shakespearean roles, has shared his thoughts on Chloé Zhao’s film, Hamnet. The film explores the tragic death of Shakespeare’s son and its potential influence on the creation of Hamlet. While it has received critical acclaim, particularly for Jessie Buckley’s performance as Agnes, McKellen expressed skepticism about the plot.
McKellen’s Critique of Hamnet
In an interview with The Independent, McKellen stated, “I don’t quite get it.” He emphasized his lack of interest in tracing the origins of Shakespeare’s inspiration, noting, “it certainly didn’t just come from family life.” Despite his reservations, McKellen acknowledged the film’s potential for Oscar recognition, albeit with some critiques of its storyline.
Plot Improbabilities
McKellen found certain elements of the plot implausible. He compared it to the 1999 Oscar-winning film, Shakespeare in Love, which he felt also presented questionable views on theatrical production. Specifically, he highlighted the unlikely premise that Anne Hathaway had never experienced a play given her husband’s profession, stating, “I think there are a few doubts of probability.”
Historical Fiction vs. Truth
It is important to note that Hamnet, based on Maggie O’Farrell’s novel, is classified as historical fiction. O’Farrell clarifies this in the book’s afterword, explaining its inspiration from the brief life of a boy who died in Stratford, Warwickshire, in 1596.
Oscar Contention
- Hamnet is nominated for eight Oscars.
- Jessie Buckley is a frontrunner for Best Actress.
- It competes against films such as Sinners and One Battle After Another.
Despite McKellen’s critique, the film has garnered positive reviews, receiving a five-star rating from Radio Times, which described it as a “masterly study of loss.” Hamnet is currently playing in cinemas across the UK, leading many to speculate about its upcoming Oscar chances.
