Nick Robinson Challenges Minister in Intense Mandelson Interview – ‘You Don’t Know!’

In a tense interview on the BBC Radio 4 Today programme, Nick Robinson challenged Labour Minister Jacqui Smith over the leadership of Sir Keir Starmer amid controversy surrounding Lord Mandelson’s appointment as a potential ambassador.

Robinson Presses Smith on Starmer’s Future

The conversation began with Robinson questioning whether Starmer was considering resignation following the growing scandal. Smith attempted to skirt the query but faced persistent inquiry from Robinson, who asked, “He’s told you he will not resign, has he?”

Starmer’s “Dark Mood”

Robinson noted that Starmer was reportedly in a “very dark mood,” prompting more direct questioning. He asked, “But do you know? Has he said it to you?” to which Smith responded, “I have not spoken to him directly about this.” This exchange highlighted the uncertainty surrounding Starmer’s leadership.

Morgan McSweeney’s Resignation

The situation intensified as Robinson addressed the recent resignation of Morgan McSweeney, Starmer’s chief of staff. McSweeney stepped down after advising Starmer to appoint Lord Mandelson, raising questions about Starmer’s accountability.

Criticism of Mandelson’s Appointment

Robinson recalled Starmer’s earlier promise to “carry the can” for staff mistakes. He criticized the decision to appoint Mandelson, emphasizing the troubling nature of his past associations. Robinson stated, “What more did the Prime Minister need to know in order to conclude – without blaming the vetting – what on earth did he need to know to say ‘as a father I will not countenance this’?”

• Smith insisted that Starmer did not fully understand Lord Mandelson’s connections at the time of the appointment.
• Robinson countered that Mandelson’s history with a convicted sex offender should have raised red flags.
• Smith admitted that the appointment was a mistake, yet highlighted that the consequences fell primarily on McSweeney.

Conclusion: A Leadership in Jeopardy

This interview spotlighted the precarious position of Sir Keir Starmer. It raised questions about leadership accountability within the Labour Party and revealed the intense scrutiny facing officials amid scandal. With key figures like Smith and McSweeney in the spotlight, the implications for Starmer’s future remain uncertain.