49ers Urged to Trade Christian McCaffrey in Upcoming Offseason
The San Francisco 49ers face critical decisions this offseason regarding their roster, particularly concerning running back Christian McCaffrey. The franchise appears reluctant to part ways with players who contributed significantly in the past. However, historical examples suggest a more proactive approach might be necessary.
Bill Walsh’s Influence on Team Decisions
The legacy of legendary coach Bill Walsh underscores the importance of timely roster changes. Walsh famously advocated for trading players a year too soon rather than a year too late. Had he been at the helm today, McCaffrey might not be on the 49ers roster.
The Current Roster Dilemma
Key players such as George Kittle, Kyle Juszczyk, and Trent Williams have anchored the 49ers in previous seasons. While they have made substantial contributions, their performance is on a downward trajectory. Kittle’s recent Achilles tendon injury further complicates any potential trades.
McCaffrey’s Recent Performance
- Missed a significant portion of the 2024 season due to bilateral Achilles tendonitis.
- Managed to play all 19 games in 2025, accumulating over 450 touches.
- Showed signs of wear by the end of the season, leaving the playoff game briefly due to injury.
Time for a Trade?
Christian McCaffrey is approaching his 30th birthday and is struggling with efficiency as a runner. In fact, the 49ers ranked 30th among 32 teams in yards per carry last season. These statistics raise concerns about the team’s running game moving forward.
Trading McCaffrey this offseason may be the most prudent course of action. His trade value is likely peaking, and with age and injury risks looming, the 49ers must consider securing assets while they can. A second-round pick would be ideal, with a third-round pick also being a viable option to consider.
Conclusion
The San Francisco 49ers stand at a crossroads. Embracing the philosophy of letting go of players at the right moment could be key to revitalizing the team for future success. Making a trade for Christian McCaffrey could help the 49ers build a stronger roster moving forward.
