“Colin Cowherd Supports Steelers’ ‘B+’ Choice to Hire Mike McCarthy”

The Pittsburgh Steelers are navigating uncharted territory after Mike Tomlin’s resignation. This marks their first head coach search in nearly two decades. Amid the uncertainty, Colin Cowherd expressed opinions about the Steelers’ decision to hire Mike McCarthy.

Colin Cowherd Reflects on Mike McCarthy’s Hiring

McCarthy was introduced as the new head coach of the Steelers on a recent Tuesday. Initially, many, including Cowherd, viewed this move as uninspired. However, after some contemplation, Cowherd reassessed the wisdom behind the choice.

Context of the Coaching Search

Colin Cowherd acknowledged that not every coaching hire can be a home run like Sean McVay. He noted, “If you’re not gonna get John Harbaugh or Kevin Stefanski, isn’t McCarthy a solid B?” This statement reflects Cowherd’s growing appreciation for the safer choice in McCarthy.

Competitive Landscape

The head coach search came after a tumultuous period. Harbaugh, initially a top candidate, swiftly opted for the New York Giants. The Steelers delayed their search with Tomlin’s resignation occurring over a week later.

• Harbaugh chose the Giants.
• The Steelers were late to the hire.
• Kevin Stefanski was also overlooked.

Steelers’ Coaching Strategy

The Steelers have historically opted for young, innovative coaches like Tomlin and Bill Cowher. McCarthy’s hiring diverges from that trend, signaling a desire for immediate competitiveness. Despite being viewed as a safer choice, McCarthy has yet to capture the enthusiasm of Steelers fans, who prefer younger and more innovative leadership.

Performance Track Record

Cowherd noted that McCarthy has successfully led potent offenses. Even in Dallas, McCarthy demonstrated adaptability. In 2024, he adapted to quarterback Cooper Rush’s unique challenges, who recorded:

Despite a mixed reception, Cowherd’s assessment of McCarthy as a B+ hire gains traction. The Steelers’ goal now is clear: to compete for a playoff spot soon. Cowherd suggests that while McCarthy may not be the long-term answer, he provides a reliable path forward for the franchise.