Steelers Hire Mike McCarthy, Analyst Draws Parallel to Kenny Pickett Draft
Pittsburgh native Mike McCarthy has officially been named the new head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers. This career move marks the fulfillment of a childhood dream for McCarthy, yet it has sparked mixed reactions among fans. Following the announcement of his hiring, many fans expressed dissatisfaction, particularly in the wake of his appointment to succeed Mike Tomlin.
Hiring Sparks Controversy
The Steelers’ choice to hire McCarthy, given his local ties, has drawn comparisons to their decision to draft quarterback Kenny Pickett in 2022. Analyst Matt Harmon discussed this parallel on the Football 301 podcast, emphasizing that the local connection often influences such critical decisions.
“It seems to be that was 60 percent of the selling point,” Harmon noted. He reflected on the Steelers’ previous experiment with Pickett, implying that the hometown connection does not guarantee success.
Kenny Pickett’s Draft Experience
Kenny Pickett was drafted by the Steelers in the first round in 2022, despite the fact he did not grow up in Pittsburgh. He played college football at Pitt from 2017 to 2021, a mere stone’s throw from the Steelers’ facilities. This proximity provided the Steelers ample opportunities to evaluate his performance closely.
- College Career: University of Pittsburgh (2017-2021)
- Draft Year: 2022
- Error in Judgment: Lasted only two seasons with the Steelers
Despite his local fame, Pickett’s tenure with the Steelers was disappointing, leading to concerns about McCarthy’s hiring following a similar logic. Many worry that the McCarthy hiring might replicate decisions that did not pan out well in the past.
McCarthy’s Coaching Credentials
Unlike Pickett, McCarthy brings extensive experience to the Steelers. He previously coached the Green Bay Packers to a Super Bowl victory and enjoyed notable success with the Dallas Cowboys. His experience illustrates a clear ability to lead and win in the NFL.
Furthermore, McCarthy has a proven track record of developing quarterbacks. This aptitude was likely a significant factor in the Steelers’ decision to appoint him, as they look to avoid the pitfalls associated with their previous pick.
Public Perception
While McCarthy’s Pittsburgh roots add a compelling narrative to his hiring, the focus should remain on his professional achievements rather than his local connections. His extensive coaching experience provides a more substantial basis for evaluating his prospects with the team.
Ultimately, McCarthy must translate his background and skills into victories on the field to ensure the success of this heartfelt homecoming with the Steelers.
