App Developer Sues Apple Over Continuity Camera ‘Sherlocking’

A lawsuit has been filed by Reincubate, the company behind Camo and Camo Studio apps, against Apple. The allegation centers on claims of anticompetitive behavior and patent infringement regarding a feature known as Continuity Camera.

Background of the Case

Reincubate launched its Camo app in 2020, allowing users to use their iOS or Android phones as webcams for Macs and PCs. However, in 2022, Apple introduced its own version, Continuity Camera, but it is exclusive to Apple devices.

Allegations Against Apple

According to the lawsuit, Reincubate claims that Apple copied key technologies from Camo. The company asserts that Apple’s control over its operating systems and the App Store has been used to diminish the appeal of Camo and redirect users to its proprietary features.

• The lawsuit asserts that Camo was utilized by numerous Apple employees across various departments.
• Initially, Apple supported Reincubate and encouraged further investment in its development.
• Once Camo demonstrated its potential, Apple allegedly took steps to undermine its functionality.

Statements from Reincubate’s CEO

Aidan Fitzpatrick, CEO of Reincubate, expressed his surprise regarding Apple’s actions. In a blog post, he recounted that Apple had internal users testing Camo during its beta phase. He stated that Apple made numerous promises to aid in the app’s development.

Fitzpatrick alleged that Apple incorporated Camo’s features into a vast array of Apple devices while simultaneously restricting Reincubate’s capabilities to innovate further. He noted that the launch of Continuity Camera was unexpected and questioned Apple’s commitment to addressing the needs of users during the global pandemic.

Wider Implications of the Lawsuit

Fitzpatrick raises concerns that the situation poses larger questions about the development environment for third-party apps. He inquired whether developers can genuinely contribute to enhancing digital experiences or if they are forced to create isolated platforms that lack significance.

Awaiting Apple’s Response

As of now, Apple has not publicly responded to the allegations set forth in the lawsuit. The outcome of this case may significantly impact the relationship between platform holders and independent developers.