NCAA Requests Recusal of Judge in Alabama Basketball Case
The NCAA has formally requested that Judge James Roberts of the Tuscaloosa Circuit Court recuse himself from a legal case involving Alabama basketball center Charles Bediako. This action follows disclosures that Roberts is listed as a donor to the University of Alabama on the Crimson Tide Foundation’s website.
NCAA’s Motion for Recusal
The NCAA filed the recusal motion on a Tuesday, emphasizing the need to protect the integrity of the judicial process. In the motion, the organization stated, “The NCAA has faith in the judicial process and does not currently contend the Court has an actual bias, partiality, or prejudice.”
Concerns About Perception
However, the NCAA raised concerns regarding the appearance of impropriety in light of media scrutiny and speculation about the judge’s relationship with Alabama’s athletics. They believe this intense public focus could undermine the proceedings.
- The motion included several articles highlighting Roberts’ donor status.
- Claims of perceived bias were noted from discussions on platforms like Reddit.
Background on Bediako’s Lawsuit
Charles Bediako filed his lawsuit on the same Tuesday, seeking both temporary and permanent injunctions. He aims to regain eligibility to play for the University of Alabama after spending three years in the NBA’s G League. After going undrafted in the 2023 NBA Draft, Bediako signed a two-way NBA contract, which the NCAA argues disqualifies him from regaining college eligibility.
Judge’s Temporary Restraining Order
On Wednesday, Judge Roberts granted Bediako a temporary restraining order, allowing him to play in a game against Missouri scheduled for that Saturday. This order was vital as it provided him a chance to participate while the lawsuit was being considered.
Hearing Postponed
A hearing regarding the injunction was set for the following Tuesday but was postponed indefinitely due to adverse weather conditions that prevented NCAA representatives from attending. The restraining order was extended for an additional ten days.
The NCAA has pointed out that even the mere appearance of partiality is sufficient grounds for recusal, according to established legal precedents in Alabama. The organization believes that due to the substantial media attention and public speculation regarding Judge Roberts’ ties to the University, recusal remains essential to uphold the proceedings’ integrity.
The University of Alabama basketball team will face Missouri at Coleman Coliseum, with the game scheduled to tip off at 7 p.m. CT on Tuesday.
