Safdie Brothers Split Tied to Controversial ‘Good Time’ Scene, Report Reveals

Recent revelations have shed light on the split between filmmakers Benny and Josh Safdie, known for hits like “Uncut Gems” and “Good Time.” Their partnership unraveled notably after a troubling incident linked to their 2017 film “Good Time.”

Background of the Safdie Brothers

The Safdie brothers gained acclaim following three successful films, establishing themselves as prominent figures in modern cinema. Their collaboration brought attention to compelling narratives and intense character studies, particularly featuring actor Adam Sandler.

The Controversial Scene from “Good Time”

The rift between the brothers reportedly began during the production of “Good Time.” The film included a contentious scene that featured a 17-year-old girl cast as a prostitute. This choice raised ethical concerns, particularly due to the scene’s graphic nature involving nudity and simulated sex.

Key Details of the Incident

• The actress was reportedly traumatized during filming.
• Benny was handling sound while Josh oversaw the shoot remotely.
• Non-actor Buddy Duress, who had a criminal record, was high during filming.
• Critics argue that the scene violated SAG-AFTRA rules meant to protect minors.

The Fallout

After the completion of the film, the Safdies decided to remove the contentious scene before its Cannes premiere, citing “creative reasons.” However, Benny discovered the actress’s age in 2022, which ignited tensions between the brothers.

Josh held Bear-McClard, a former producing partner, responsible for the hiring decisions related to the actress. Meanwhile, Bear-McClard disputed this claim, stating he was not present during the incident. This led to the Safdies severing ties with him and initiating the dissolution of their production company.

Breaking Point and Subsequent Projects

Despite continued collaboration for nine months, the brothers’ partnership came to a head in March 2023. This was shortly after a report emerged detailing Bear-McClard’s divorce filing and the events surrounding the “Good Time” incident. Consequently, their planned film featuring Adam Sandler and Ben Affleck was abruptly canceled.

Following their split, Josh moved forward with the project “Marty Supreme,” starring Timothée Chalamet, while Benny took on “The Smashing Machine” with Dwayne Johnson.

Current Status of the Brothers

The Safdies have not publicly reconciled. Recent reports suggest they attended the same wedding but were seated at separate tables and are currently not on speaking terms. Benny has indicated that their careers have always involved individual pursuits, reflecting their earlier days in film school.

A Possible Competitive Angle

The timing of these revelations coincides with Josh’s film “Marty Supreme” gaining momentum for awards consideration. Some speculate that the details surrounding their split may have been leaked to undermine this campaign.

The future of the Safdie brothers as collaborators remains uncertain, as their creative paths diverge further. While they have a shared history, ongoing tensions suggest that a reunion is unlikely in the near future.