Buddy Review: A High-Concept Horror That Explores a Deadly Twist | Sundance 2026

Buddy, a new entry in the horror genre, premiered at Sundance 2026, captivating audiences with its unique twist. Directed by Casper Kelly, known for his work on Adult Swim, the film adopts a nostalgic look reminiscent of 90s children’s shows. The central character, Buddy, an orange unicorn, is not your typical friendly face. Instead, he poses a disturbing threat to the children who adore him.

Synopsis and Themes

The film unfolds in a vibrant television studio, where children’s programming seems inviting but conceals darker undercurrents. Buddy’s character, voiced by Keegan-Michael Key, initially appears as an enthusiastic companion. However, his escalating violent tendencies — including stabbing and decapitations — swiftly turn the narrative grim, leaving audiences questioning Buddy’s true nature.

Characters and Performances

• Buddy: Voiced by Keegan-Michael Key, Buddy’s cheerful demeanor hides his sinister side.
• Delaney Quinn: Stars as one of the kids who gradually realize Buddy’s deadly intentions.
• Cristin Milioti: Plays a confused parent who believes her daughter is missing, echoing themes from her previous roles.

Narrative Structure

As the storyline progresses, children become aware of Buddy’s malicious actions, prompting them to devise strategies for survival. The film oscillates between the children’s plight in the show and a confused parent’s storyline in reality. This duality, however, lacks cohesion, making it difficult for viewers to invest emotionally in the characters.

Critical Reception

While Buddy aims to carve out a niche in the horror landscape, it falls short of the greatness of past Sundance breakouts like Get Out and Hereditary. Critics note that Buddy’s violent antics and a colorful setting reduce the film’s impact. Despite moments of potential horror, the film struggles with pacing and character development, rendering it less effective in delivering genuine scares.

Conclusion: A Missed Opportunity

Buddy explores high-concept horror, meshing childlike innocence with deadly intentions. However, the film fails to deliver a compelling narrative or memorable thrills. The overall execution leaves audiences wanting, as Buddy ultimately does not live up to the expectations set by the beloved horror genre.