Federal Judge Denies DOJ’s Request to Detain Minnesota Protesters
A federal judge in Minnesota has denied the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) request to detain two protesters involved in a demonstration at a St. Paul church. This church is allegedly linked to a pastor who works with the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
Judicial Ruling on Protesters’ Detention
U.S. District Judge Laura M. Provinzino stated that the DOJ failed to show that a detention hearing was necessary. The defendants, Nekima Valdez Levy-Armstrong and Chauntyll Louisa Allen, are charged in connection with the protest. However, the details of the case remain largely sealed since not all defendants are in custody.
Charges Against the Protesters
- The charges involve the federal FACE Act, which protects reproductive facilities and houses of worship.
- The federal magistrate found no probable cause to charge the defendants under the FACE Act.
- Levy-Armstrong and Allen face a single count of conspiracy against constitutional rights.
This law, originating from the post-Civil War era, criminalizes conspiring to “injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate” individuals exercising their constitutional rights. This statute was also referenced in the allegations against Donald Trump regarding attempts to overturn the 2020 election results.
Details of the Protest
The demonstration involved approximately 30-40 individuals who disrupted a church service. According to the sealed affidavit, their actions caused panic among parishioners, including children, and led to injuries during the chaos. One female parishioner reportedly fell while fleeing.
Responses from the Parties Involved
Attorneys for Armstrong and Allen have not provided comments. The DOJ also did not issue a response immediately following the ruling. Leading the case for the DOJ are attorneys Robert Keenan and Orlando Sonza, along with Kristian C.S. Weir from the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Minnesota.
Government’s Evidence Questioned
The judge criticized the government’s arguments, stating there was “no factual or legal support” for categorizing the protest as a “crime of violence.” She concluded that both defendants have established ties to Minnesota and did not exhibit any intentions to flee.
White House Reaction
The White House has been involved in the situation, posting an altered image of Levy-Armstrong that depicted her as crying during her arrest. This post has drawn criticism, leading a senior official to label it as a “meme.”
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem had shared the original image of Levy-Armstrong calmly arrested. White House officials affirmed that law enforcement actions will continue, stating that “the memes will continue” as well.
