NYT Confirms Ross Not “Run Over” by Renee Nicole Good

The incident surrounding the death of Renee Nicole Good has sparked a substantial national conversation about law enforcement practices and use of force. Conflicting reports regarding her encounter with Agent Jonathan Ross reveal key details about the event, which occurred on January 7 in Minneapolis.

Overview of the Incident

On January 7, 2023, Renee Nicole Good was fatally shot by federal agent Jonathan Ross during an altercation involving her sport utility vehicle (S.U.V.). Videos of the incident have come under scrutiny, particularly a cellphone recording released by the agent, which has been interpreted in various ways.

Key Facts from the Video Analysis

• Contrary to initial claims, the New York Times confirmed that Good did not run over Agent Ross.
• There was physical contact between the hood of Good’s car and the cellphone in Ross’s hand.
• Ross positioned himself in front of Good’s vehicle while she attempted a three-point turn.
• The video shows Ross leaning into the car as it approached him, leading to gunfire.

Following the shooting, President Trump and members of his administration asserted that Good “weaponized her vehicle” against Ross, a claim that has been disputed by local and state officials. They argue that federal tactics and aggressive strategies were primarily responsible for escalating tensions.

Public Response and Federal Involvement

After Good’s killing, protests erupted across the nation, demanding justice for her death. In response, the federal government dispatched an additional 1,000 agents to Minnesota to maintain order.

Expert Analysis on Use of Force

Reports suggest that Ross’s actions align with a controversial U.S. Border Patrol policy that has been criticized for allowing agents to place themselves deliberately in dangerous positions. An internal review from the Police Executive Research Forum indicated:

• Agents often stepped in front of moving vehicles to justify the use of deadly force.
• There is a chronic lack of accountability and thorough investigation in fatal shooting incidents.
• Recommendations include avoiding confrontation with moving vehicles to protect both law enforcement and civilians.

The findings raise significant questions about Ross’s decision-making protocol at the time of the incident. Had he opted to step aside rather than engage, it’s suggested that Good might still be alive today.

Call for Accountability

This incident underscores a broader issue of police practices and accountability. Critics argue that Ross’s actions warrant investigation, rather than attributing blame to Good or local leaders. The need for reform in law enforcement practices has never been more apparent, as the nation grapples with the implications of this tragic event.

As more information becomes available, the call for justice and reform will likely intensify, with advocates emphasizing the need for a reassessment of use-of-force policies in law enforcement across the country.