Roger Ebert Walked Out of This Oscar-Winning War Film
Renowned film critic Roger Ebert is known for his passionate reviews, yet few films evoked strong reactions like the 1991 Oscar-winning war film “Mediterraneo.” Directed by Gabriele Salvatores, this Italian comedy-drama focuses on Italian soldiers stationed on the Greek island of Megísti during World War II. Ironically, Ebert, who dedicated his life to cinema, found this film utterly displeasing.
The Plot of “Mediterraneo”
“Mediterraneo” centers on a group of Italian soldiers entrusted with monitoring the remote island of Megísti. Their original mission takes a turn when their pickup ship is bombarded by Allied forces, trapping them on the island. Initially believing the island to be deserted, they soon discover local inhabitants hiding from the war. As the soldiers integrate into island life, romantic relationships blossom, and memories of battle begin to fade.
A Film to Remember for All the Wrong Reasons
Despite its heartwarming premise and eventual Oscar win for Best Foreign Language Film in 1992, “Mediterraneo” struck a sour note with Ebert. He expressed his disdain in a 1996 interview with Entertainment Weekly, where he stated it was the only film he had ever walked out of, characterizing it as “utterly without redeeming merit.”
Box Office Success
- Release Year: 1991
- Oscar Win: Best Foreign Language Film (1992)
- US Box Office Revenue: $4.55 million
Roger Ebert’s Critical Legacy
The Contradictions of a Film Critic
In other reviews, Ebert praised Gabriele Salvatores’ later work, including the 2003 film “I’m Not Scared,” which earned three and a half stars. This raises questions about what specifically frustrated him about “Mediterraneo.” While acknowledging its success at the Academy Awards, his personal distaste remains a notable aspect of his legacy.
Ultimately, Ebert’s reaction to “Mediterraneo” suggests a complex interaction between personal taste and critical acclaim in the world of film.
