Cowboys Face Disaster in Round 1 if These 3 Names Are Drafted

The Dallas Cowboys have a critical decision ahead in the 2026 NFL Draft, especially regarding their defensive needs. With the goal of securing two starting defenders in the first round, the Cowboys must tread carefully. Certain high-profile players are being suggested as potential fits, but several carry significant risks that might not justify an early selection. Here, we examine three players the Dallas Cowboys should consider avoiding in Round 1 of the draft.

Cowboys Face Disaster in Round 1: Three Players to Avoid

1. Akheem Mesidor, EDGE, Miami (FL)

Akheem Mesidor showcases impressive attributes including size and pass-rush capabilities. His college career exhibited productivity across various defensive schemes. However, his age and injury history raise valid concerns for Dallas.

• Age Concern: At 25, Mesidor is entering the league at an advanced age for a rookie. Historically, players entering the NFL at 24 or older have faced challenges.
• Injury Issues: Mesidor has undergone multiple foot surgeries, adding to the risk of selecting him early.
• Track Record: His breakout at 24 could signal limited potential for improvement.

While emerging as a first-round prospect, Mesidor might not be the best investment for Dallas, which may benefit from selecting a younger player with more upside.

2. C.J. Allen, LB, Georgia

C.J. Allen is widely praised for his character and football intelligence. His ability to connect with teammates is unmatched. However, doubts remain regarding how his skills will transition to the NFL level.

• Size Limitations: Allen is considered undersized for a linebacker and lacks the necessary length to dominate at the next level.
• Physical Concerns: Notably, he did not participate in the NFL Combine, raising questions about his speed and explosiveness.
• Injury History: Having faced health issues, including a meniscus surgery in 2025, his durability is in question.

While Allen shows promise as a potential quality linebacker, he may not merit a top 20 pick, particularly given his physical challenges.

3. Jermod McCoy, CB, Tennessee

Jermod McCoy stands out as the most talented player among the three. He displayed dominance during his sophomore year, with remarkable performance on tape. Yet, injuries cloud his selection prospects.

• Health Risks: Despite his impressive 4.40 40-yard dash time, he struggled with explosiveness during Pro Day drills.
• Injury Recovery: Skipping the Senior Bowl and Combine signals that McCoy may not be fully recovered from previous injuries.
• Potential Risk: The Cowboys need immediate contributions, making McCoy’s uncertain health a crucial factor against drafting him.

While his skills indicate high potential, the risk associated with selecting McCoy may outweigh the benefits for the Dallas Cowboys.

As the draft approaches, the Cowboys must weigh their options carefully. Avoiding these three players could lead to wiser choices that better align with their needs and future goals on defense.