White Lotus comparison surfaces in explosive Pump Rules Season 12 reunion trailer
The trailer for the Season 12 reunion centers on cousins Jason Cohen and Chris Hahn being grilled over an OnlyFans scandal, with multiple cast members likening the controversy to a white lotus scene. Reunion host Andy Cohen presses the cast on whether the cousins’ collaboration on sexual content crossed a line.
Trailer frames the controversy
In clips from the two-part taping, cast members accuse Jason Cohen and Chris Hahn of engaging in incest after it was revealed they collaborated on sexual content on OnlyFans. Andy Cohen asks the group, "On a scale of nothing to 'White Lotus, ' how bad was it?" The comparison invokes the shocking Season 3 scene in which brothers Lochlan Ratliff and Saxon Ratliff — played by Sam Nivola and Patrick Schwarzenegger, respectively — engage in incest.
How the allegation surfaced
SUR worker Israel Isaac sounded the alarm over the cousins' content in episode 7 of the revamped series. Israel first told co-star Angelica Jensen, who then read an extremely explicit caption from the boys' OnlyFans page aloud. Jensen refused to watch the video but quickly shared the revelation with co-stars Kim Suarez and Demy Selem.
Demy Selem’s description
Demy Selem watched the video and described it as involving four men, two of them being Jason and Chris. "It's a lot of massaging, a lot of butts, I've seen everyone's penis. Now someone's in the shower... " she said to Jensen and Suarez before throwing the phone down horrified. She added, "There was definitely incest. They were all touching each other. "
Cast lines and confrontations
The trailer also spotlights on-set blowups and multiple tense confrontations. Audrey Lingle and Angelica Jensen reopen an Instagram scuffle; Audrey says she has been "brutalized on social media" and blames Angelica for "starting it, " while Angelica retorts, "You're not the only one. " The exchange escalates until Audrey tells Angelica, "Shut the f**k up! F*ck you because you f*cking started it, you b*tch!"
Other moments and reactions
Backstage, Lisa Vanderpump is told, "I'm excited about this, " and she replies, "I love all of them right now. Right now it's pure. " On camera, Jason predicts, "It's gonna be a slimy day, I think. " Marcus Johnson jokes about his sexuality, saying he is only about "80 to 90 percent straight. " Andy asks, "You have a baby pact with Shayne?" and Shayne Davis answers, "She would like to have my genes. " In another exchange, after Venus seemingly suggests he doesn't trust Kim, she shoots back, "You're so delusional, " and Kim butts heads with Natalie Maguire amid accusations that Natalie had too close a friendship with her boyfriend Marcus.
Direct questions and defenses
On the reunion set Andy Cohen also asks pointed questions about personal relationships. He asks Chris Hahn, "How far is too far for you guys?" and at another point presses Chris point-blank about whether he was sleeping with another woman; the camera pans to Chris looking down without answering. Jason has defended his OnlyFans output during a recent appearance on a talk show with Andy Cohen, insisting he always "keep[s] it classy. " On the specific cousin video, Jason said coyly, "I think it had really good qualities that all the people that bought it were really happy with. "
Angelica Jensen, speaking last month to interview hosts Danny Murphy and Evan Real, described finding Jason and Hahn's content "dark" and "weird. " "I don't judge them for having OnlyFans, but I was judging them for the content... for what I believed it to be, " she said.
Part 1 of the Season 12 reunion airs March 3 at 9 p. m. ET. The trailer makes clear the taping will revisit the episode-7 revelations and the string of personal confrontations that followed, leaving the cousins and the rest of the cast facing intense scrutiny.
