The Traitors Season 4 Episode 9: Rob’s covert power play, Dorinda’s exit and Stephen’s banishment set the stage for the finale
Episode 9, which landed Wednesday, Feb. 12 (ET), reshaped the endgame on The Traitors with a second-time murder victim, a mid-season recruitment twist, and a misread banishment. With only two episodes left, eight contestants remain — six Faithfuls chasing two Traitors — and momentum tilting toward a quiet frontrunner.
The night’s defining moves
Rob Rausch tightened his grip on the castle by recruiting Eric Nam as a Traitor, presenting him with a stark choice to join or be eliminated. Eric accepted, acknowledging the heavier lift ahead after recent whispers about his subdued gameplay. The recruitment arrives at a critical moment: the Faithful had just rallied to oust back-to-back Traitors, yet Rob remains largely insulated from suspicion.
Dorinda Medley was murdered on Tuesday, Feb. 11 (ET), marking the second time she has been taken out by Traitors across two seasons. Her departure also wipes the last of the Housewives contingent from the game following earlier eliminations, further narrowing alliances heading into the final stretch.
Inside the box mission
The mission locked players into enclosed boxes while Traitors slipped away to answer hot-seat prompts like “Who is the most manipulative?” and “Who is most useful to the Traitors?” The Faithful needed to predict those answers to add to the prize pot, but the real intrigue came from the social reads the exercise invited. Rather than turning the answers into a breakthrough, the castle spun its wheels, and suspicions failed to consolidate on the right targets. The Traitors’ selections — and how closely they tracked the house’s perceptions — offered breadcrumbs, but the Faithful couldn’t convert them into a decisive lead.
Why Stephen was banished — and Johnny wasn’t
Stephen Colletti’s game unraveled in a close vote that pitted him against Olympic figure skater Johnny Weir. The case against Stephen stemmed from the optics of him receiving gold during a critical mission and the optics of private talks with a now-banished player, both of which curdled into a narrative he couldn’t shake. Natalie’s read that Stephen felt inauthentic at breakfast compounded the pressure. When challenged, Stephen doubled down on his Faithful status but struggled to reframe the timeline or redirect heat toward more plausible suspects. Johnny survived, and the Traitors banked another faithful elimination without burning their cover.
Rob’s cover holds as Eric joins the dark side
Rob’s social game continues to be the season’s most effective shield. Despite two consecutive Traitor banishments prior to this episode, votes have not cohered against him. Key players have repeatedly voiced trust in Rob, even as he orchestrates pivotal swings in the shadows. His recruitment of Eric adds a layer of unpredictability: Eric, already scrutinized for being too quiet, now must play faster and cleaner under the radar while syncing with Rob’s tempo. Kristen Kish appeared to clock the possibility of a newly minted Traitor, zeroing in on Eric’s change in temperature — a tension to watch with only a couple of roundtables left.
Housewives era ends — and what it means
With Dorinda’s murder, the last remaining Housewife is out. Across the season, that subset struggled to escape early targeting and cross-show narratives that often swamp gameplay. Their exit thins a once-dominant bloc, redistributing social capital to reality competitors with stronger challenge résumés and to players from dating shows who’ve blended in more seamlessly. That shift subtly advantages Rob and Eric, who benefit when familiar lightning rods leave the board.
The road ahead: dates, dynamics and a shrinking field
Eight players remain: two Traitors (Rob and Eric) and six Faithfuls. The finale is set for Thursday, Feb. 26 (ET), with a reunion hosted by Andy Cohen slated to follow immediately after. The key questions before then: Can Kristen firm up her read on the new Traitor and rally votes in time? Will Eric’s adjustment period expose seams in the duo’s cover story? And does Rob’s near-impenetrable trust bubble finally burst — or carry him straight to the firepit endgame?
After Episode 9, the scoreboard favors deception. The Traitors dodged heat, steered a faithful banishment, and removed a nonessential target overnight. Unless the Faithful can convert mission clues and breakfast-room tells into a coherent case by the next roundtable, the castle’s most trusted presence may also be its most dangerous.
