Brendan Banfield Denies Conspiracy with Au Pair in Double-Murder Trial Testimony
A Virginia man, Brendan Banfield, is on trial facing aggravated murder charges for the deaths of his wife and another man. The alleged crimes took place in February 2023. If convicted, Banfield could face life in prison.
Brendan Banfield’s Defense Testimony
Banfield took the stand to share his account, maintaining his innocence throughout the proceedings. He claims there was no conspiracy with his family’s au pair, Juliana Peres Magalhães, despite accusations from prosecutors. They allege that Banfield and Peres Magalhães plotted to lure Joseph Ryan to their home under false pretenses, framing him for his wife’s murder.
Details of the Allegations
- Date of Incident: February 24, 2023
- Accused of plotting with au pair to kill wife, Christine Banfield.
- The alleged motive: An extramarital affair and a scheme to disguise the murder.
During his defense, Banfield described his relationship with Peres Magalhães, which started in August 2022. He stated that they had an affair, but clarified that it would not end his marriage. Banfield emphasized, “There was no plan with Juliana on February 24.” He recalled the morning of the incident, detailing an important work meeting ahead and a planned birthday celebration with his daughter.
The Day of the Incident
On the day of the murders, Banfield stopped at a McDonald’s for breakfast. While there, he received a distressed call from Peres Magalhães. When he attempted to contact his wife, the call went directly to voicemail, an unusual occurrence. Concerned, he instructed Peres Magalhães not to enter their home and returned immediately.
Upon arrival, Banfield found his wife, Christine, severely injured. He claims he shot Ryan in self-defense after witnessing the latter attacking his wife. Both he and Peres Magalhães subsequently called 911 to report the incident.
Prosecution’s Evidence and Witnesses
Testimonies and evidence presented by the prosecution claim that Banfield staged the scene, moving Ryan’s body and attempting to manipulate evidence. Peres Magalhães has since changed her stance, testifying against Banfield. In October 2023, she was arrested for Ryan’s murder and agreed to cooperate with prosecutors in exchange for a lenient sentence.
- Witness Testimony: Peres Magalhães alleged Banfield staged the crime scene.
- Key Evidence: Banfield’s DNA was absent from the murder weapon.
Banfield’s defense attorney accused prosecutors of coercing Peres Magalhães into framing Banfield, claiming police ignored digital evidence that undermines their theory. A digital forensics expert testified that data from the couple’s devices does not support the prosecution’s claims of “catfishing” Ryan. Banfield asserted he never accessed his wife’s devices without her knowledge.
Next Steps in the Trial
As the trial progresses, Banfield is expected to continue his testimony. The defense strategy carries significant risks, particularly as he faces cross-examination. The case continues to unfold, leaving the jury to determine the credibility of Banfield’s claims versus the accusations presented by the prosecution.
