Manchester United’s Paradox Explained
Manchester United’s performance in the current Premier League season reveals a complex paradox. Despite achieving solid results against top teams, the squad struggles against average opponents.
Manchester United’s Position in the Premier League
As of now, Manchester United holds 35 points, placing them 5th in the Premier League, trailing 15 points behind leaders Arsenal. This season has presented a mixed image for the team, especially in their encounters with Arsenal, a historic rival.
Historical Context of Rivalry
Recently, Manchester United has consistently faced Arsenal with a significant gap in the league standings. Over the past three seasons, the teams have competed with a difference of 5 to 6 positions on the table. Their last six meetings show that Arsenal has dominated, winning five and drawing once.
United managed to secure only one victory against Arsenal in the FA Cup during the last three years. However, their performance in their latest clash was commendable, despite Arsenal winning. United recorded 22 shots, over 61% possession, and created multiple scoring opportunities, yet could not secure a win.
Impact of Managerial Changes
The fortunes of both teams diverged after that match. Arsenal continued their successful run, while the Red Devils faced a steep decline. The dismissal of former manager Ruben Amorim led to a gradual improvement, culminating in a notable victory against Manchester City. Ironically, this win benefited Arsenal in the title race, extending their lead over City to seven points.
Performance Against Strong Teams
Notably, Manchester United has proven challenging for strong teams this season. They managed to defeat Chelsea, Liverpool, and Newcastle, who are currently excelling in the Champions League. Furthermore, their win against Manchester City highlighted their potential against powerful opponents.
Inconsistency Against Average Teams
The core issue for Manchester United remains their inconsistency against weaker teams. Historically, from the Solskjaer era through Ten Hag and Amorim to interim manager Carrick, the team has often excelled against high-caliber rivals while faltering against low-tier opponents.
This trend suggests that Manchester United struggles with maintaining competitive form overall. The team’s counter-attacks, spearheaded by Bruno Fernandes and dynamic wing play from Diallo and Dorgu, can be effective. However, Fernandes has shown only modest capabilities, and his teammates have performed even worse.
The Path Forward
Despite significant financial investment in players over the past decade, Manchester United fails to play at a top club’s level. They often deliver surprising performances similar to teams like Crystal Palace against stronger clubs.
Moving forward, Manchester United could rekindle their title aspirations, yet they remain far from competing for the championship. Addressing their inconsistent performances against average teams will be crucial for future success.
